Hearing protection at the range comes down to two things: a noise reduction rating (NRR) you can check on the package, and a fit you will still wear after an hour. Most of the plugs below are foam. Five of the eight are foam, and the other three are reusable plugs: two with flanges and one adjustable.
The order runs from the best all-round pick to the most specialised. Each entry says who it suits, so you can skip to the type you need and then read How to Choose for the trade-offs.
How to Choose
Compare NRR first. Each foam plug here is rated in NRR. Five foam plugs sit at 32 to 33 dB. The Peltor is 26 dB, and the SureFire EP4 is 24 dB with its filter caps in. The Loop Switch 2 is rated in SNR (20 to 26 dB), a different measure, so compare it on its own numbers.
Foam, corded or adjustable. Foam is the lowest-cost route, and the 50-pair Walker's and Mack's Ultra Soft packs are the two lowest-priced here. A corded plug like the Peltor stays on its cord when not in use, which the features say helps reduce the chance of loss. An adjustable plug like the Loop Switch 2 lets you change the noise level without changing plugs.
Pick the pack by how often you go. The 50-pair packs from Mack's Ultra Soft, Walker's, Covert Ops and Ear Buddy cover a long season. Howard Leight comes in 10 pairs and Peltor in 3. Match the count to your range trips rather than the sticker price.
Check the fit with headgear or muffs. The SureFire EP4 is low-profile and designed to stay in place under a mask, helmet, hat or supplemental hearing muffs. If you would rather wear muffs, see our guide to shooting ear muffs. The Peltor is listed as great for shooting or hunting and for indoor and outdoor use.
Keep them clean and in one place. The Peltor's 3-pair pack includes a storage container, and the Mack's Ultra Soft ships in a flip-open jar. Keep your plugs in your range bag with the rest of your range kit so they are always on hand.
FAQ
What noise rating do I need for the range?
The NRR is printed on each package and is the number to compare. The five foam plugs here run from 32 to 33 dB. Walker's, Mack's Ultra Soft and Howard Leight sit at the top of that range at 33 dB.
Can I wear earplugs with muffs?
Yes, with the right plug. The SureFire EP4 is built to stay in place while you wear supplemental hearing muffs, and its low profile fits under a mask, helmet or hat. Check the fit with your own muffs before a range day.
Do I need an adjustable plug, or is foam enough?
Foam is enough for most range shooting. The Loop Switch 2 is the only adjustable plug in this group, with three selectable modes. It is the right choice if you want to hear conversation between shooters and then drop to the strongest setting.
Final Thoughts
Mack's Ultra Soft Foam Earplugs is the top pick: 33 dB, 50 pairs and the largest review count in the group. Walker's PU Foam Earplugs is the budget pick for 50 pairs with the same 33 dB rating. If you need a reusable plug with a cord, look at the Peltor. If you need to change the noise level on the fly, the Loop Switch 2 is the one to choose.